By-products in pet food: what they are and whether they’re bad
By-products are the animal parts left after the muscle meat is removed, mainly organs such as liver, heart and kidney. They aren’t bad by definition and can be very nutritious. Their quality varies, though, so who makes the food matters more than the word on the label.
What are by-products?
The word describes what’s left of an animal once the muscle meat, the part most people in the US eat, has been removed. Tufts University’s veterinary nutrition team says these are mainly organ meats and entrails, such as liver, heart and kidney.
The name tells you which parts were used. It doesn’t tell you about their quality, safety or nutrition. Tufts also notes that a brand can list organs by name, such as “liver,” and still advertise “no by-products.”
What can’t they include?
Rumors about what goes into by-products often go further than the rules do. For mammals, the AAFCO definition cited by Tufts specifically leaves out:
- Hair, hooves and horns
- Hide trimmings
- Manure and intestinal contents
- Anything that isn’t part of the carcass, such as floor sweepings
Poultry by-products are a separate category and can include heads, feet and entrails. That’s the main difference from chicken meal, which excludes those parts.
Are by-products bad for dogs and cats?
Not by themselves. Tufts says that, weight for weight, by-products often provide more nutrients than muscle meat. Using them in pet food also keeps edible animal parts from going to waste.
The real issue is consistency. Rendered by-product meals vary widely in quality, and you usually can’t see that on a label or website. Research also describes large differences in protein content and digestibility among animal by-product meals.
One 2023 study in 12 beagles found chicken by-product meal was less digestible than deboned chicken in high-protein diets: 83% of its protein versus 90%. All the diets were well tolerated and the dogs stayed healthy. The study was small, tested specific ingredients and was funded by Champion Petfoods, so it doesn’t apply to every by-product.
Which pets should be careful?
- Pets with a food allergy: “chicken by-products” are still chicken. Vague names such as “meat by-products” don’t say which animal they came from, so ask the brand or choose a food that names the source.
- Pets with a sensitive stomach: the whole food matters more than this one ingredient. If your pet has loose stools or other symptoms, talk to your vet.
How to judge a food with by-products
- Look for a named source: “chicken by-product meal” tells you more than “animal by-product meal.”
- Look at the maker: Tufts advises choosing companies with strict quality control, which matters more than whether a food contains by-products.
- Be wary of “no by-products” as a selling point: it doesn’t prove a food is better.
- Look at the whole food: check that it’s complete and balanced for your pet’s species and life stage.
Common questions
Are by-products in dog food bad?
Not by definition. They’re mainly organs and other parts left after muscle meat is removed, and they can be very nutritious. Quality varies, so the manufacturer’s quality control matters.
Do by-products contain hair, hooves or feathers?
For mammals, the AAFCO definition cited by Tufts excludes hair, hooves, horns, hide trimmings, manure and intestinal contents. Poultry by-products can include heads, feet and entrails.
Is chicken meal better than chicken by-product meal?
Not automatically. They’re made from different parts, and quality depends on the source and processing. A label can’t tell you which is better in a specific food.
Should I avoid foods with by-products?
There’s no need to avoid them for that reason alone. If your pet has an allergy or health condition, check the animal source and talk to your vet.
See how a food fits your pet
Snap the label and SavChu reviews it against your pet’s allergies, life stage and health conditions.
Scan a labelSources
- Tufts Petfoodology: Don’t be bothered by by-products
- Tufts Cummings School: Nutrition FAQs
- AAFCO: What’s in the Ingredients List?
- Sieja et al. (2023), Journal of Animal Science: high-protein diets differing in protein source in healthy adult dogs
- Journal of Animal Science: protein digestibility of animal by-product meals for dogs
Written by the SavChu team. Last reviewed: October 30, 2026.
General nutrition information, not veterinary advice. Talk to your vet about your pet’s diet.